Best mascara - TOP 5 ranking in 2025
We present a ranking of the best mascaras to help you achieve long and thick lashes, enhancing your look. Choose a lengthening mascara that will provide a lengthening and thickening effect, thanks to special formulas containing lengthening fibres. The right brush also plays a key role, making it easier to apply mascara precisely and stretch lashes. Our TOP 5 ranking presents the highest quality mascaras that provide an intense lengthening and volumising effect. Discover our suggestions and enhance your beauty with the best mascara available on the market.
The ranking factors we took into account are:
- Lengthening
- Durability
- Brush
- Consistency
- Composition
- Effect
- Quality
What ingredients to look for in good mascara?
Waxes, such as beeswax or carnauba wax, have a use in keeping the mascara formula on the lashes. They serve to add volume and highlight the appearance of the hairs.
Pigments: these give the mascara its colour. These can be different shades of black, brown or other colours that add definition to the look.
Nutrients: vitamins, proteins or plant extracts that nurture the lashes and promote their healthy appearance.
Fatty acids, such as linoleic acid, are used to soften lashes and prevent them from drying out, which contributes to their elasticity and condition.
Preservatives: To extend the life of mascara and prevent bacterial growth, preservatives are used to protect the product from spoilage and keep it in the right condition for use.
Take a look at our mascara ranking:
Nutridome lengthening and thickening mascara is a real hit in eye care! This unique formula not only intensively highlights lashes, but also makes them longer and fluffier. Thanks to the rounded brush, application is precise and effortless, and the effect lasts all day. What's more, the mascara's composition, enriched with rice wax and panthenol, further conditions the lashes, protecting them from breaking. Performance is also impressive. Studies have confirmed the product's effectiveness and safety, making it an ideal choice for vegans. Nutridome curling mascara is a must-have in every beauty bag!
Inglot Promise lengthening mascara is a solid choice for those with sensitive eyes. The hypoallergenic formula means it can be used with complete safety, which is a big plus. Although slightly less pigmented than some competing products, it gives lashes a natural, subtle look, perfect for everyday wear. Testers liked the precise, small brush, although the mascara dries quickly both on the lashes and in the packaging. The mascara doesn't crumble or bounce on the eyelids, which is important. Despite the slightly higher price tag, Inglot Promise is a worthwhile value for those looking for a gentle mascara for everyday use. The biggest downside is its tendency to dry out quickly, making it difficult to use up completely as it becomes unusable.
Doll Eye Mascara from NYX Professional Makeup promises a thickened and lengthened lash effect. Thanks to the special hourglass-shaped brush, application of the product is easy and precise. The formula, enriched with a blend of plant oils and vitamin E, not only cares for the lashes but also provides intense, long-lasting black colour. In addition, the nylon fibres optically extend the lashes, although this is a rather subtle effect. The Doll Eye mascara performs quite well, providing a crisp look all day long. Unfortunately, the mascara tends to clump lashes and create clumps that settle on the brush. It dries quickly, so requires some skill in application, but the visual effect is satisfactory.
Volume Reveal mascara from Bourjois is a solid choice for those looking for a thickened lash effect. The product performs quite well, giving lashes volume and a defined effect. An added bonus is the practical mirror, which makes application easy even on the go. The brush precisely brushes the hairs, which makes it easier to cover the mascara evenly. Despite its minor flaws, Bourjois Volume Reveal mascara deserves attention for its effectiveness and practicality. However, it is important to note the product's longer drying time and tendency to shed at the end of the day, which is surprising for its high price.
Lancome Definicils Mascara offers a subtle, natural effect of lengthened and slightly curled lashes. However, given its high price, we would have expected more impressive results. The mascara can clump lashes together and can be flaky by the end of the day. The stiff brush is difficult for some to use and can potentially irritate the eyes. The level of pigmentation is also quite poor and requires several coats of mascara for optimal results. Lancôme Définicils is not a bad mascara, but its price can put people off and the quality does not match it.
