Best eyeliners - TOP 5 ranking in 2025
Beautifully crafted lines on the eyelid can revolutionise a look, giving it greater expression. With hundreds of eyeliners available on the market, choosing the right product becomes a challenge. The solution is to use an eyeliner ranking that tells you what to look for when choosing. It is advisable to choose products that are long-lasting and intensely pigmented, especially for beginners who may prefer pen eyeliners that are easier to use. Our ranking takes into account key features such as durability, colour intensity and ease of application to help you choose the perfect product for your eye make-up. Dive into the world of eyeliners and discover which one will highlight your uniqueness!
The ranking factors we took into account are:
- Durability
- Precision
- Pigmentation
- Price
- Performance
- No irritation
- Composition
What ingredients to look for in good eyeliners?
Pigments: They are responsible for the intensity of the eyeliner colour. They can be natural, but there are also synthetic equivalents.
Water: commonly used as a carrier for the ingredients contained in eyeliner. Thickening agents: Contain xanthan gum or cellulose, which help to maintain the consistency of the product.
Moisturising ingredients: Emollients are moisturisers and emollients, such as vegetable oils or waxes, which make eyeliner easier to apply.
Pearl pigments or mica: most commonly found in glitter and metallic eyeliners, they are responsible for the shimmer and shine effect.
Fixing ingredients: They ensure that make-up lasts by keeping the eyeliner on the skin.
Take a look at our ranking of the best eyeliners:
Eyeliner by NUTRIDOME is an absolute hit when it comes to creating a glamorous look. From the first use, it impressed with its ease of application and precision. Thanks to the convenient design, creating the perfect line becomes child's play. The pigmentation is intense and the deep black highlights the eye in a striking way. In addition, the simple and safe composition with natural activated charcoal and panthenol, providing protection for the delicate eyelid skin, makes this eyeliner indispensable in your daily make-up routine. Streak-free, fast-drying and long-lasting - it does exactly what we expect from a good eyeliner. And all this at an affordable price. A well-deserved top of the list!
NYX Professional Makeup Matte Liquid Eyeliner surprises with its pigment intensity and precise applicator that allows you to create perfect lines no matter how thick they are. Its convenient-to-use pen is perfect for creating an alluring cat-eye look. Despite promises of durability, the product does not hold up flawlessly when in contact with water, which may be a downside for those expecting reliable waterproofness. In addition, the lack of conditioning ingredients and the relatively high price may put off some users. This doesn't change its high rating and for lovers of precise and intense lines, the NYX Matte Liquid Liner eyeliner is an option worth considering
Eveline Precise Brush Liner 24H, is an interesting choice for lovers of precise eye make-up. Its thin tip ensures accuracy, allowing you to create perfect lines. The longevity of this eyeliner is commendable and although it is slightly less than the promised 24 hours, it must be said that it lasts for a long time. Although the pigmentation is good, the black may be a little too glossy for some. However, its main strengths - precision and staying power - make it worth a try, especially for those with some make-up application skill, as it is a little too runny and one false move could mean having to start again.
Gel eyeliner from Maybelline is a popular choice among many people looking for long-lasting eye make-up. While it has many benefits, it is not a product without its drawbacks. The two-tip jar form may be practical during application, but it also takes up more space in a make-up bag than traditional pen eyeliners. There have been heads up that the applicator tip is a little too thick, which can make it difficult to draw lines accurately. Also, although the pigmentation is good, the consistency of the gel can change slightly after a few hours of wear, which can be a little annoying for those expecting perfection all day long. Despite these drawbacks, Maybelline eyeliner remains a solid choice for those who value long-lasting and glamorous eye make-up.
Max Factor Masterpiece Eyeliner, despite its benefits, did not live up to our expectations and came last in the ranking. Although it has a precise tip, which makes application easier, and provides long-lasting make-up, its main drawback is its low pigmentation. The lack of deep black makes the effect unsatisfactory. In addition, the product tends to dry out, which makes it difficult to apply after a while. The high price and small content (only 1 g) further reduce the attractiveness of this eyeliner, as over time it starts to resemble a running out marker. As a result, although functional in the short term, it fails to live up to expectations in terms of colour intensity and performance.
